 |
The
Devon Karst Research Society.
The
Homepages for the
CATTEDOWN
BONE CAVES,
Cattedown,
Plymouth, Devon, England, U.K.
Section
18.0. SHAPTER'S FIELD AND FOX'S FIELD,
CATTEDOWN
EAST QUARRY (PRINCE ROCK QUARRY AND THE OLD CORPORATION QUARRY), CATTEDOWN.
Cattedown
Thru' Cave and Cattedown Pigeon Cave.
Text
revised on 16 April 2007. |
|
18.1....INTRODUCTION
:
An entry in the 1877 edition
of the
Three Towns Directory for Plymouth, Devonport and
Stonehouse, indicates that " .... Wm. Johns Shapter, dairyman ....",
was a tradesman resident at Cattedown, where, presumably, he was grazing
his dairy herd. This is the only reference that we can source for the possible
origin of the word "Shapter", in the context of naming the area.
Subsequent to this, the
Shapter's
Field area became an area for garden allotments and then subsequently
a base for a U.S. Military Garrison during the 2nd World War, using Nisson
Huts for accomodation. After this period of use, this important karst area
then became a commercial scrapyard for motor-vehicles. In the last decade
of the 20th century, the land was cleared and largely quarried away for
the construction of a low-quality light industrial business area - "The
Plymouth Trade Park".
Fox's Field is the
limestone area, still partly surviving, immediately to the north of Shapter's
Field. Historically, this has been used by various Gas Utility Companies
and still contains an operational gasholder. Environmentally, this area
is of great importance and may be dealt with separately in a dedicated
Webpage.
The
purpose of this Section 18. is to offer further details of
this largely destroyed limestone grassland area in what was until the very
end of the 20th century, one of the few surviving unimproved karst surface
areas of the original "Cat Down". The area was extremely cavernous. What
remains of this area now is hardly discernable thanks to the incompetence
of the so-called "competent authorities" amongst which the Plymouth City
Council looms larger than most. We have lost forever the treasures of the
karst underground representing vast quantities of the fossil record. This
destruction will also be detailed.
Looking
to the future, we shall also greatly detail the little of this area that
survives to be studied in the future. The Society's deep regret is that
we could probably have stopped the destruction had we not been otherwise
engaged in other long-term karst issues elsewhere in South Devon. As far
as we are concerned, the successes we achieved with karst preservation
in various other parts of South Devon were paid for by the losses at Cattedown.
This is irreconcilable. |
|
18.2....LOCATION
OF SHAPTER'S FIELD AND W.B. MOORE'S / THE OLD CORPORATION QUARRY :
.
.
The location of Shapter's
Field can be best described as the area of unquarried land situated
between the westerly limits of Prince Rock Quarry and Cattedown Middle
Quarry. The far western section of this quarry was once operated by W.B.
Moore and was later to become the Corporation Quarry, having subsequently
been owned and operated by the Pymouth City Council's Works Department.
The earliest photograph
we have of Shapter's Field currently dates from 1931 and was taken in the
context of the developing Oil Terminal Installations and includes the north-western
parts of Prince Rock Quarry. The most complete view of Shapter's Field
is shown in Photo 18.2.1. below, viewed from an aircraft.
The photo on the left is
a very interesting historical record of the north-western part of Prince
Rock Quarry, indicating the following industries, activities and features
other than the Oil Industry :-
In the Quarry
Area :-
1...W.B.
Moore's Limestone Quarry in the background is providing limestone for the
Lime Kilns situated in the bottom-right of the view, opposite the Oil Terminal
on the other side of Oakfield Terrace Road.
2...The
limestone is being transported out of the quarry by horse and cart.
3...In
the bottom-left corner is the Lomas Gelatine Works.
4. The road crossing
diagonally up from the bottom-right to the middle-left, terminating in
an unfinished condition, is Maxwell Road.
In the Shapter's Field
Area :-
5...In
the extreme top left corner is the Higher Cattedown Road (Cattedown Lane),
with its stone walls on either side.
6...Shapter's
Field itself seems to be grassland.
PHOTO
18.2.1...(left):
A
view of the north-western part of Prince Rock Quarry showing the B.P. Oil
Terminal Installation, Oakfield Terrace Road, Cattedown, before the Company's
merger with Shell-Mex on 01 Jan 1932.
Note
the Shapter's Field limestone grassland at the top of the Image and the
Higher Cattedown Road just within view in the very top-left corner.
(Photo
: Surrey Flying Services, Croydon Aerodrome, Surrey, dated 1931.,
from the Shell UK Oil Plymouth Terminal photo-archive. 979 kB.) |
|
18.3....HISTORICAL
USE OF THE SHAPTER'S FIELD AREA AND THE PRINCE ROCK QUARRY :
The Prince Rock Quarry (the
most easterly of the Cattedown Quarries) is the largest of the quarries
on the Cattedown Peninsula. It was originally operated by various limestone
extraction companies, mostly small family concerns, who over the course
of more than a century, combined into fewer but larger operations. The
names of Moore, Symons, Sparrow and Scott are
all connected historically with mineral extraction or lime production in
the Cattedown area.

PHOTO-MONTAGE
18.3.1...(above)
:
A
view looking towards the western quarry face of Prince Rock Quarry. The
view shows the development of the B.P. & Shell Mex Oil Terminal's No.
1. Site and the Plymouth City Engineers' Depot just in view on the right.
Above the quarry face is a
complex
of abandoned temporary buildings - accomodating a former US Military Base
during the 2nd World War. Behind this in the far distance is the Mount
Batten Civil War Artillery Tower.
To
the left on the line of the Higher Cattedown Road can be seen H.M. O.S.
Triangulation Pillar atop the support base for the earlier chimney stack
of Burnard & Alger's Chemical Works, formerly situated in the Cattedown
Middle Quarry on the other side.
At
the foot of the quarry face in the top-left corner of the view is the entrance
to the East Portal of the masonry-lined Railway Tunnel.
The
road in the bottom-left is Maxwell Road. The new road separating the Oil
Terminal and the Plymouth Corporation Works Department is Macadam Road.
(Photos
: unknown, from the Shell UK Oil Plymouth Terminal photo-archive,
No. R34. [left, 947kB.] and part of R35. [right, 322kB.], both dated 07
November 1950.)
|
|
PHOTO
18.3.2...(left):
The
view shows in the background at the top of the quarry face, the Shapter's
Field area being used as a motor-vehicle scrapyard, with cars piled up.
In
the foreground is the northerly limit of of the B.P. & Shell Mex Oil
Terminal's No. 1. Site and beyond the galvanized sheet-metal fence is the
Plymouth City Enginerrs' Depot, separating the Oil Terminal from the Plymouth
Corporation Works Department is Macadam Road.
The
gasometers are situated in Fox's Field., on the northern ground
of the Cattedown limestone, where it slopes gently downwards to join with
the lower-lying slates and shales at Coxside.
(Photo
: unknown, from the Shell UK Oil Plymouth Terminal photo-archive,
No. R34. dated 07 November 1950. 279kB.) |
THE
CATTEDOWN "REGENERATION" SCHEME.
THE
DEGENERATION AND DESTRUCTION OF A UNIQUE LIMESTONE KARST ENVIRONMENT -
THE
LEGACY OF INCOMPETENCE :
Destruction
of Shapter's Field, Cattedown.
pdf. file, 132 kB. incl.
4 x images |
18.4....THE
CATTEDOWN "REGENERATION" SCHEME -
THE
DEGENERATION AND DESTRUCTION OF A UNIQUE LIMESTONE KARST ENVIRONMENT -
THE LEGACY OF INCOMPETENCE :
A substantial part of this
very inappropriately-named project involved the complete removal of the
surviving part of Shapter's Field. The principal contractor for this work
was T.J. Brent.
Please click on the Link
opposite in the left-side column to view a .pdf
document
summarizing the destruction of the karst area. The document is a product
of T.J. Brent, who refer to a
"Shapter's Field Quarry". This was
in fact the Old Corporation Quarry, formerly owned and operated
by the Works Department and the City Engineer's Department of the pre-Unitary
Authority Plymouth City Council. Their view of the project was, of course,
very up-beat and positive. When considering the amount money they received
for this work, they would obviously be positive!! However, as a result
of this work, T.J. Brent now rank high in the list of those responsible
for karst-environmental destruction in this County.
The mention and detailed
consideration in this Webpage of this particular event in the so called
"development" of Cattedown is highly relevant to the task in hand. As previously
mentioned, Shapter's Field was, until the very late 20th century, one of
only three remaining "unimproved" areas of the original "Cat Down" karst
plateau area. The area has now been removed and a large part of a wonderful
cave system has gone with it. The cave system was
breached because of the ill-advised decision of the Plymouth City Council
to clear land for the development of yet another low-qualtiy Trade Park,
presumeably resulting in a very short-term gain to the mismanaged Treasury
of the City. The whole process leading up to this event is surrounded in
controversy and is still being investigated by the Society. In this connection,
various individuals once in the employ of the City Council have offered
very interesting information.
However, it should be noted
that there is much more scope for the continuation of this type of "development"
or, more correctly - "karst environmental
degeneration and destruction" at Cattedown. If left unchallenged,
our hapless political "leaders" (the term is used advisedly) would
probably get away with it and without having to account for their incompetence. |
THE
CATTEDOWN "REGENERATION" SCHEME.
A
RECORD OF THE DESTRUCTION OF A CAVE SYSTEM -
THE
LEGACY OF INCOMPETENCE :
|
THE
DESTRUCTION OF A CAVE SYSTEM - THE LEGACY OF INCOMPETENCE :
Cattedown
Thru' Cave and Cattedown Pigeon Cave.
PHOTO
18.4.1...(left):
This
general view illustrates the completed and stabilized western quarry face
of the former Corporation Quarry, with very little of the former Shapter's
Field area remaining above.
These
cave passages are part of the same cave system, as their adjacency would
indicate.
They
are completely different in their speleogenesis and subsequent development
than those further south on the Cattedown Peninsula, beyond both the postulated
synclinal structure and another large structural geological feature located
further south again..
(Photo
: B. Lewarne, 26 April 2003. 320 kB.)
Photo
18.4.2...(right):
A
more detailed view of the very large walled-up cave passages in the quarry
face at the eastern flank of the surviving area of Shapter's Field.
The
limestone quarry face is covered with steel mesh, which has been further
anchored in place.
These
two Images can be seen in greater context in the Photo-montages below.
(Photo
: B. Lewarne, 26 April 2003. 551 kB.)
|
| WESTWARD
REGRESSION OF THE EASTERN
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
«---..................
Following
on in this direction (south) from the adjacent Photo-montage 18.4.4.
is the Plymouth Abattoir Site.
«---...................
|
BOUNDARY
OF THE SHAPTER'S FIELD / CORPORATION QUARRY AREA AND ASSOCIATED CAVE SYSTEM
:
  
.
PHOTO-MONTAGE
18.4.3.
The
above series of Images depict a cross-section (from left to right and south
to north respectively) of the heavily karstified Middle-Devonian Limestone
geology along the final position of the regressed Corporation Quarry faces
comprising the new westerly limit of the Prince Rock Quarry (Cattedown
East Quarry), as seen in late 2000. In the process of having to avoid fencing
barriers, it was not possible to record the images from exactly the same
point. However, we think we have captured the information to a useable
quality.
This
cross-section depicts the varied and interesting relationship of the cave
passages with the structural geology and lithology of the limestone. The
above view has been interpreted by others as being a cross-section across
a syncline, within the base of which most of the cave system has formed.
This
is an over-simplistic interpretation. Sources external to the Society have
also determined that the base of the syncline appears to be located at
ca.18m
(59 feet) AOD. The positions of the walled-up cave passages can be clearly
seen.
Another
locally-important structural geological feature is indicated further south
again, in the left-two Images above. The position of this latter feature
marks the boundary between the difference in cave evolution (speleogenesis)
of the caves positioned on either side.
The
fence running along the top edge of the quarry face marks the line of a
section of the extant Higher Cattedown Road, now an extinguished highway,
which once crossed the grassland-covered limestone plateau of "Cat Down".
(Photos
: B. Lewarne, 13 October 2000.)
 
.
PHOTO-MONTAGE
18.4.4.
The
above series of Images depict the southerly continuation of the cross-section
in the Photo-montage 18.4.3. above, again running from left to right
and south to north respectively.
(Photos
: B. Lewarne, 13 October 2000.)
|
| CATTEDOWN
THRU' CAVE and CATTEDOWN PIGEON CAVE. |
THE
CAVE SYSTEM BENEATH THE SHAPTER'S FIELD AREA :
The
walled-up breached cave passages, indicated in the Images above, belong
to the Cattedown Pigeon Cave and Cattedown Thru' Cave System, which itself
is a part of an even greater cave system within the Cattedown Karst Peninsula.
This particular part of the cave system, originally beneath the Shapter's
Field limestone grassland. was first surveyed by the Plymouth Caving
Group in December 1963 and who, under the leadership of P. Price, produced
a "Grade 4" cave survey.
Their
cave survey managed to account for an estimated 700 feet (213.4m.) of accessible
cave passage and it indicated a labyrinth of passages and chambers forming
the comparatively small interconnected air-spaces at cave-roof level above
huge quantities of natural cave-infill sediments. These sediments are sealed
at their top surface within the cave passages by thick layers of stalagmitic
floors, referred to as "false floors". Many of the cave chambers had inaccessible
passages and rifts leading off in various directions. The cave survey
indicates some structural geological control over the direction in which
many passages developed. As is the case with many other such cave systems
in South Devon, these cave passages are mostly filled with cave sediment
and breakdown materials, masking their full vertical extent. [A copy
of this early survey is held in the Society's Library and Archives Facility.]
This
part of the cave system lies within a locally-important structural geological
feature, the location of which is indicated in the second and third Images
from the left in Photo-montage 18.4.3. above. This feature has been
interpreted as a syncline, with a base at approximately ca.18m (59
feet) AOD.
Cave
chambers and passages act as both mixing and storage areas for the clastic
sediments that they contain. Such cave sediments represent the input brought
in from the surface by sinking streams entering via ponors; soil washdown
from the epikarst and as the residual insoluble fraction remaining after
dissolution of the limestone. Materials from these sources are mixed in
conduit caves, differentiated according to density and particle size and
further transported through the conduit aquifer when water flows through
the aquifer reach the necessary thresholds. When hydrological activity
under phreatic conditions gradually develop into vadose streamflows and
then cease altogether, the remaining in-situ cave sediments, containing
a wealth of palaeo-environmental evidence, may then be subjected to the
effects of dripping and flowing of lime-rich authigenic water within the
cave. This may well have the effect of depositing layers of stalagmite
on top of the cave sediments and sealing them in position. This is what
has happened in the passages and chambers of Cattedown Pigeon Cave and
Cattedown Thru' Cave.
A
large part of this scientifically-valuable and irreplaceable fossil record
at Cattedown has been lost to science forever, just because the Plymouth
City Council wanted to develop the area for low-quality industrial units!!
The
extant remains of the Cattedown Pigeon Cave and Cattedown Thru'
Cave will be described in a dedicated Link-Page, currently
in preparation. |
HANSON
QUARRY PRODUCTS.
THE
PROPOSED FURTHER DESTRUCTION OF A CAVE SYSTEM -
THE
CONTINUATION OF THE LEGACY OF POLITICAL INCOMPETENCE, INTRANSIGENCE AND
TOTAL DIS-INTEREST : |
.
The southerly extension
of the limestone grassland of the Shapter's Field area would have been
in the south-west corner of the Prince Rock Quarry (or Cattedown West Quarry).
The monochrome Images in Photo-montage 18.3.1. show this area in
its post-quarried condition, with the East Portal of the Cattedown Railway
Tunnel shown in the top-left corner. This situation had arisen by about
1890, by which time the quarries faces in this corner of the area had been
progressed as far west as could be achieved without undermining the Higher
Cattedown Road above.
After the turn of the Century,
this area was gradually taken over by the railways serving the storage
and distribution depots of the expanding Oil Industry. In this area, just
to the south of then extant Shapter's Field but on land to the immediate
north of the East Portal of the Cattedown Railway Tunnel, the Plymouth
Corporation Abattoir was constructed along with associated hide- and bone-processing
factories. These installations survived until the 1990's when the redundant
Abattoir was demolished. The Abbatoir Site was laid out on ground adjacent
to and contiguous with the Scheduled Ancient Monument of Worth's Cattedown
Bone Cave. This small parcel of land was prime development property and,
unknown to the Society, was sold off by the Plymouth City Counil to Hanson
Products, who wished to construct a concrete-batch manufacturing plant
on the location.
Further details regarding
the recent history of this parcel of land are beyond the remit of this
specific Webpage. Please refer to the Special
Link Page "Actual and Potential Threats to the Caves and Karst of the
Cattedown Peninsula", where details of the recent story
about this area are detailed in a dedicated Webpage.
PHOTO
18.4.5...(left)
:
The
Image depicts the southerly limit of the Shapter's Field "development"
area, stopping next to the site of the old Plymouth Abattoir, here under
demolition.
The
tree-covered quarry faces date from the 1890's and are currently extant.
(Photo
: B. Lewarne, 13 October 2000. 205 kB.)
|
 |
|....CBC
Section 17....|....Cattedown
Homepage....|....Next
- CBC Section 19....| |